Movie Mirrors Index

Laughing Sinners

(1931 b 72')

En: 4 Ed: 5

This morality tale of a jilted dancer who joins the Salvation Army is based on the play Torch Song by Kenyon Nicholson.

Ivy (Joan Crawford) has been the lover of traveling dress salesman Howard (Neil Hamilton) for two years. Not having seen him for two weeks, she joyfully greets him at the train station; but he can only spend two days with her. She is obviously very much in love with him. While she is singing him a torch song in the night club where she works, he is figuring out how to leave her because he is getting married. At a friend's suggestion he just writes her a note on a menu and disappears. Two months later she is stopped from jumping off a bridge by Carl (Clark Gable), who wears the uniform of the Salvation Army. He invites her to their picnic the next day; she shows up and enjoys helping the children and getting to know Carl, who found this life after he spent two years paying for his wrongs.

The Salvation Army has another attractive young woman named Edna. A year later Howard meets her and is going to take her out when he sees Ivy in uniform. Thinking she would only join such a group if she were down and out, Howard offers to help Ivy; but she is not interested in what a married man has to offer on the side. Later Carl and Ivy talk things over, and he says goodnight. Howard calls her and discovers she is in the hotel room next door. She says she does not want to meet him but reluctantly opens the door. He says he wants her back and gradually re-awakens the old feelings in the woman he used to call Bunny; she follows him into his room and spends the night there. In the morning Howard is called out by friends to revive a girl they got so drunk she is unconscious. The drunk older salesman Cass Wheeler (Guy Kibbee) gives Ivy liquor, and she starts dancing. Carl comes in and is horrified by what he sees. Ivy says that she is going to go back to her old job and that the part of herself that is Bunny can no longer be repressed. Carl loses his temper and hits Howard in the face. Then he tells Ivy that we all stumble; but after we fall, we have to get up and go on until we find ourselves. Howard makes fun of this sermon, but in the end Ivy is seen back in uniform walking with Carl.

This story attempts to take on the prejudices of usual movie audiences to groups like the Salvation Army. Ivy herself has a low opinion of them at the start, but a glimpse of the helpful work they can do for the poor and those who need help changes her mind and may reach a few hearts in the audience as well. Surely this is a better choice for her than being used occasionally by a married traveling salesman. One hopes that once the hurt of that affair is healed, she'll probably find a more healthy relationship.

Copyright © 1999 by Sanderson Beck

Movie Mirrors Index

BECK index